Find & Compare Unique Stays in Long Island, NY

Discover a unique stay in Hampton Bays at this one-of-a-kind hexagonal cottage, set within 1.6 kilometres of local amenities and nestled in private woodland.
This unusual accommodation offers 316 square metres of space for 8 guests, featuring spa-worthy bathrooms and two pianos for a truly memorable experience.

Discover an unusual accommodation on 1.6 private acres, just 800 metres from Orient Point County Park beaches and a short drive from Orient Beach State Park.
This historic farmhouse offers a heated outdoor pool with hot tub, ample space for 10 guests, and a separate den for children, promising a unique stay.

Just 1.6 kilometres from the beach, this Fairfield farm offers a tranquil country escape an hour from New York City.
This unusual accommodation is perfect for large groups with two homes, a seasonal pool, hot tub, outdoor kitchen and pizza oven for a unique stay.

Just 800 metres from the ocean beach, this Sagaponack compound offers a unique stay on 9 secluded acres.
This luxurious farmhouse boasts 836 square metres of space for 16 guests, featuring a 17-metre infinity pool and a 1/4 acre playground for an unusual accommodation experience.

Discover this modern 2-bedroom cabin in a quiet White Plains residential area, offering a unique stay with convenient access to local amenities.
Enjoy this spotless 42 square meter half-basement apartment, complete with a kitchen, air conditioning, and a shared garden, perfect for up to 4 guests.

Just 1 hour from Penn Station, this bungalow offers a unique stay in Long Beach, ideal for Atlantic Ocean sun salutations.
Enjoy a 'grill & chill' atmosphere in this family-friendly, 3-bedroom bungalow with a garden and internet.

This Cutchogue farmhouse, a delightful 1700s property, offers a unique stay just a short walk from Hallockville Museum Farm and Shinn Estate Vineyards.
Boasting 325 square metres and accommodation for 12, this unusual accommodation features a hot tub, gym, and extensive gardens for a memorable getaway.

Docked in Sayville, this houseboat offers direct access to Fire Island's shoreline, just 700 meters from Carrington House and the Fire Island Lighthouse.
This 36-foot trawler, a truly unique stay, boasts two bedrooms, two bathrooms, a full galley, and a flybridge, perfect for exploring Sailor's Haven and The Pines.

This island accommodation in Roslyn, Long Island, offers a peaceful suburban setting, a short walk from Roslyn Village's restaurants and 10 kilometres from LIRR train stations with direct service to New York City.
Enjoy a unique stay in this 167 square metre island property featuring a private backyard with a massage chair and a dedicated kids play area, perfect for up to six guests.